To Be or Not To Be...A Bench

A few weeks ago, I finally had a few minutes to stop into our newest Goodwill shop. So many times I wanted to go in, but didn't for one reason or another. Luckily, I picked a great day to stop by. There were so many great pieces of furniture that particular day, but this one really spoke to me. It is a twin headboard and footboard set, and was a steal at only $13 bucks! They told me that I had to take the rails and I really did not want them, but now I am so glad that I kept them. They are solid wood!

My first thought was a bench. Then, I thought, this could be two separate benches! My vision was a cream-colored bench upholstered with burlap and nailhead trim, then my vision went to black paint. I can't make up my mind! One bench or two, cream or black, to upholster or not to upholster...

This little beauty has great details! I love the circles, they remind me of a wedding ring quilt, and the very top arches inward, making it very unique. It does not have a maker's name on it, but it is very nice. Even the footboard has extra details that would really shine as a bench. If I choose to paint it cream with a glazed finish, the glaze would fall into the crevices and really make it look great. If I go with black the round metal accents would stand out even more. Decisions, decisions. The footboard could be used as the front of the bench or I could build it out with different legs and use the footboard for a smaller child-sized bench.

Tell me what you think- leave comments and give me your ideas for this piece, even if you don't see it as a bench. I had to have it, now just have to decide what to do with it. Oh, and I have to decide whether to keep it or sell it! Maybe I will put it up for sale, and if I have no takers then I can keep it! Sounds like a plan to me...

Comments please!

Thanks for your advice
~Misti

Edit: Go check out Layla's place to see her awesome ideas for my bargain, piece...she is so cool!